Linking the thought from the video in my previous post, The Real Truth About Fiat Money and the Banking System, I came across an article from the recent edition of the Business Times Weekend explaining how inflation occurs in Singapore. In it the author, Senior Correspondent Teh Hooi Ling, explains that it was through watching the video titled "Zeitgeist-Addendum" on YouTube that eventually lead her to think how money supply in Singapore is created despite the government running a budget surplus year after year.
By definition M2 is the money supply in Singapore consisting of currency in active circulation, demand deposits of the private sector, fixed deposits, Singdollar negotiable certificates of deposits, savings and other deposits. At the end of 2000, M2 stood at S$170.9 billion. By end Nov 2010, M2 had exploded, more than doubling to S$401.4 billion. That's an increase of 8.9% p.a. for the past 10 years. In comparison, the data given in article stated that GDP had grown only about 6.4% p.a. during the same period.
So how does money supply grow in Singapore?
For that I'll leave you to the author herself to explain, extracting a part of the article so you can read it verbatim, highlighting what I felt were the important bits to take note of.
"I came across a document entitled Monetary Policy Operations in Singapore on the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) website. The 32-page document highlights the key aspects of MAS's monetary policy policy operations, and the various factors and considerations underlying them.
The four primary responsibilities of MAS are:
- Implementation of exchange rate policy;
- Conduct of money market operations for banking system liquidity management;
- Management/issuance of Singapore Government Securities (SGS) in support of government initiatives in bond market development; and
- Provision of banking and financial services to the government
MAS's balance sheet looks like this:
On the assets side, a big chunk is in foreign assets, i.e. the official foreign reserves of Singapore. MAS also holds an inventory of SGS. It also has domestic credits, that is lending to banks in the course of conducting money market operations for liquidity management in the banking system.
On its liability side, the biggest component is government deposits. These are surpluses that the Singapore government run year after year. Also in this pool are contributions of members to the Central Provident Fund (CPF). Also on the liability side is currency in circulation. Under the provisions of the Currency Act, each Singdollar must be fully backed by foreign assets. As we all know, Singapore's monetary policy targets neither the interest rate nor monetary aggregate. It is centred on the trade-weighted exchange rate. As such, the monetary base is also endogenous, and its level is based more on banks' demand for reserve and settlement balances.
So this is my understanding of how the money supply of Singapore has been growing all these years. Say a foreign company wants to set up factory in Singapore because of the good infrastructure here and the convincing marketing campaign by the Economic Development Board.
The foreign firm brings in US$100 million. It needs to convert that amount to Singapore dollars to pay for the construction cost of its building, to pay utilities bills and salaries of its staff. So demand for the Singdollar increases. If the aggregate demand for the Singdollar far exceeds the supply in the market, the local unit will appreciate too fast and make Singapore exporters uncompetitive. So since MAS's mandate is to manage the Singdollar's trade-weighted exchange rate, it will intervene by selling Singdollar to meet the demand and buy the US dollar.
That's how money supply in Singapore grows over time. Among other reasons, demand for the currency also rises when Singapore exporters want to convert revenues in US dollars back to Singdollar, or when foreign investors are keen to invest, say, in real estate in the Lion City, given its safe haven status and its emergence as a global city.
I've charted how Singapore's GDP in current market prices and how Singapore's M2 money supply have grown since 1980. The ratio of M2 to GDP has been rising through the years. Prior to 1998, total M2 had always been lower than the aggregate GDP. But that changed in 1998, and by end of 2009, M2 is 140% that of Singapore's GDP. Is it a wonder then that real estate prices have been so bouyant in the last few years?"
Source: The Business Times Weekend
Title: How Money Grows in Singapore
Section: Show Me The Money
For the curious and those with lots of time to spare, I've linked the Zeitgeist-Addendum video as well as the follow up movie below.
Cheers,
~K
Zeitgeist-Addendum
Zeitgeist-Addendum II
Hi Kay, thank you for contributing your thoughts in this blog. I would like to add my two cents worth if you don't mind.
ReplyDeleteThe article saysSo "....(MAS)will intervene by selling Singdollar to meet the demand and buy the US dollar." The question is HOW? I would suggest that they merely print more Singapore dollars and inject it into the economy through banks. Banks will then loan this out through fractional reserve banking, inflating the base currency up to 10 times. That's how you get your 90% bank loan to buy properties, inflating the property prices. Some people would make money selling properties at the now inflated prices. They have more money to spend and bid up the COE prices. That is how Inflation is created.
Hi Fhoo Keong,
ReplyDeleteThanks for your injection of fresh information on the increase in money supply. It brightened my day knowing that people are still reading my blog despite me being inactive for the last couple of months due to work commitments.
Cheers,
~K
K,
ReplyDeleteInteresting read! Thanks for sharing.
Exact same question as Fhoo Kheong and arrived at the exact same answer.
Sadly... correspondents earning their makan at The Sh*t Times seldom... or can't do critical thinking/reporting. Even if they did, editors' in the way. Run far away from SPH if you wanna be a rich kid! Saves you some money too.
"Under the provisions of the Currency Act, each Singdollar must be fully backed by foreign assets."
Say... in the mainstream of things, USD is considered foreign asset, rite? USD = World Reserve Currency! Power rite?! So... accordingly, our SGD is backed by USD, is it not?
But is not USD a promissory note by the US govt? A debt? Something they can print heartily and with much ease?! Hah! So what good is it that our SGD is backed by other people's promises?!
This 'Currency Act' of ours is nothing more than a promise of a promise! Gives the clueless some sense of security doesn't it? Now you know... so is it not a fallacy?!
But alas, we but a small nation need to play along with this currency musical chair game... and this game is about up my friend... the writings on many a walls. Question is... will our tiny shrimpy Singapore get a chair when the music stops?
I see you found James Turk... so I reckon you know about gold. Ever tried charting Gold vs SGD? Try it if you haven't and go see using inflation eyes. By the way, in case you not know, 'inflation' also = 'silent theft by Govt'.
Let's hope our tiny shrimpy Singapore has her own golden chair to sit comfortably... when the music stops.
Humbly,
RedHill